My friend is getting my other friend the same present for her birthday that I am getting her?

My friend's birthday is coming up (on December 1) and she thinks Pillow Pets are really cute and today I was looking through store brochures and I wanted to see what Five Below was selling and I saw that they had Cudlee Pets. Which look like Pillow Pets and are only 5 dollars! I can't afford to buy her anything expensive because I only have 10 dollars and I don't want to make my mom pay since she has to take me to the dentist next week and we don't have insurance. Anyway, I told my other friend I was planning to buy her a Pillow Pet and she said "I want to get her that" I was kinda mad because I had been thinking of getting her that for like 2 weeks now and she knew that. And then she said "You can get her a Pillow Pet, just not the one I'm getting" Ugh :\ I don't know what to get her now! She's turning 12 and I can't go to the mall since pretty much everything there is expensive. She likes Abercrombie but that's way too much money for me to spend and I don't know if I should still get her a Pillow Pet. Can anyone please tell me what I should do? She also likes earrings